Comparison of Satellite-Based Soil Moisture Estimates
and Rainfall Data for a New Mexico Watershed

 

Background       Study Area      Data      Methods      Results & Conclusions

 

To compare rainfall and soil moisture data, 31 SMAP grids for the month of August 2018 covering the study area were loaded into ArcGIS.  Time increments between SMAP data grids vary between approximately 11 and 37 hours (see Figure 4, orange boxes). Point precipitation data from tipping bucket gages was examined, and eight storms were identified during the study period (Figure 4, blue arrows).

Figure 4: SMAP grids (orange) with corresponding time stamps (UTC) and measured cumulative precipitation between consecutive grids (blue arrows).

 

Soil moisture values for each time increment and three grid cells were extracted in ArcGIS, and changes in soil moisture between subsequent grids were calculated. Figure 5 shows an example for August 22-23, 2018 for grid cell 1. Soil moisture in the indicated grid cell (yellow outline) changed from 0.07 to 0.18 m3/m3, a positive change of 0.11 m3/m3.

Figure 5: Example of change in soil moisture (m3/m3) for one grid cell between two subsequent SMAP grids.

 

Zonal average precipitation was calculated for the time periods between subsequent SMAP grids. Figure 6 shows cumulative rainfall for the SMAP grids displayed in Figure 5.

Figure 6: Example of accumulated rainfall in grid cell 1 for the time period between the SMAP grids shown in Figure 5.

 

NEXRAD precipitation data are often biased (i.e. systematically higher or lower than ground observations). Rain gages were therefore used for bias correction. To accomplish this, accumulated precipitation for each storm was extracted from the NEXRAD grid at each gage location (see Figure 6, yellow circles) using spatial analyst tools. Figure 7 compares NEXRAD and rain gage data at each gage location for the August 22-23 storm. The comparison illustrates that – with some exceptions – gage data was higher radar-derived rainfall estimates. NEXRAD zonal averages for each grid cell were therefore scaled using the median ratio of gage and radar data (in this case 1.50).

 

Figure 7: Comparison of rain gage (red) and NEXRAD (blue) precipitation accumulation for the storm of August 22-23, 2018.